Property owners are responsible for deciding how they want their rental units to look. Some opt for standard appliances and fixtures to save costs. This also allows renters to enjoy more affordable rent. Some decide to focus on enticing amenities that wow potential tenants. How can you know what’s right for you?
Carpet vs. hardwood flooring lies at the center of this question. Carpet may be a bit outdated, but it’s certainly more affordable. Hardwood flooring, on the other hand, has become something of the norm due to its aesthetic appeal. What type of flooring would work best for your rental property? We’ll explore the pros and cons of each to help you decide.
Carpet vs. Hardwood Flooring in Rental Units
What are the Pros and Cons of Carpet?
Carpet has fallen out of popularity, but it still offers several advantages such as:
- There’s nothing like cozying up on a soft carpet floor. With hardwood flooring, rugs are often necessary for added comfort and warmth. Carpet is comfortable all on its own, and it makes a space feel homey.
- Less noise. You won’t hear the echoing of loud noises with carpet. This type of flooring absorbs sound, making for a quieter home. This is especially beneficial for apartment complexes multiple tenants share.
- Added safety. If you take a tumble, carpet will cushion the fall. It’s much less dangerous compared to other types of flooring, which makes it ideal for children and the elderly.
- Decreased cost. Carpet can be installed over subfloors, and it doesn’t require additional prep during the installation process. Since it’s also not as trendy as it once was, buyers can enjoy spending less on flooring.
At the same time, there are a few negatives to be aware of:
- Prone to stains. Spills and messes require a bit more clean-up compared to hardwood floors. Property owners may have to hire a professional carpet cleaning service before new tenants move into the unit.
- Allergens. Carpet floors tend to collect dust, pollen, pet dander and other allergens. This can be a major disadvantage for individuals with asthma or allergies. Carpet is also known for absorbing smells like cigarette smoke, which can be a problem for property owners.
- Old-fashioned. Today, carpet isn’t exactly considered a modern choice. In some spaces it can look outdated and cheap. However, it’s worth noting that trends change all the time. The 70s revival is in full swing, so shag carpet may become attractive to renters and homeowners in 2023.
What are the Pros and Cons of Hardwood?
Carpet vs. hardwood flooring is a tricky decision, but hardwood is more popular for a reason. Here’s why:
- A clean, updated look. You can’t beat the look of hardwood. Its simple, classic, and beautiful appearance will continue to appeal to tenants.
- Easy to maintain. Hardwood requires minimal maintenance. Upkeep is necessary, but the cleaning process is much easier compared to carpet.
- Many different options. Hardwood offers a range of options from a rustic, old-world hickory to a glossy teak. You can totally customize the look of your hardwood flooring depending on what style you’re going for.
- Good investment. Renters and homeowners prefer hardwood, which makes it a good investment down the line.
The cons of hardwood flooring include:
- Higher cost. Hardwood has a higher aesthetic appeal and a more complex installation process, so it tends to cost more. Property owners have to decide if its benefits outweigh the costs.
- Noisy and less safe. Renters will hear every footfall and loud noise on hardwood floors, and they creak more and more as time passes. The hard surface of hardwood also makes injuries much more likely if someone in your family falls on the floor.
- Damage over time. Hardwood floors are prone to scratching, bumps, water damage and even termites. These are things every property owner should consider before making a purchase.
What’s More Important: Cost-Effectiveness or Aesthetic Appeal?
Carpet vs. hardwood flooring? The decision isn’t an easy one, but ultimately it depends on your renters. Knowing your audience is key. What are they looking for? Are cost savings more important to them, or does aesthetic appeal reign? There is no doubt every property owner has their own preferences, but they should think about their tenants first. Choosing carpet vs. hardwood flooring can make or break someone’s decision to make your property their home.
Partner with All County Denver Metro, Your Go-To Property Management Company
All County Denver Metro Property Management is here to give property owners confidence in the quality of their tenants and the security of their property through knowledgeable and trustworthy property management services. From managing tenant relationships to pricing rent to lease enforcement, we look forward to working with you to see how your investment can be a long-term, stress-free asset. For a complimentary quote or information about carpet vs. hardwood flooring, call us today at (720) 575-6100.
